What Did You Think Of Idol Last Night?

[leelee88]

You know I was not to much a fan of Christys, But I am strarting to really like her voice when she sings country. She sang one of my favorite songs last night "Anyways" By Martina Mcbride..

And Little David I really enjoyed him..

And the song Jason song Over The Rainbow, In the differant version I think was really awesome..

So what did you all think about them last night?

[lisabar36]

I missed the show last night. :( I never miss it, well try not to. I was so busy with my daughter and by the time I thought about it, it was to late. So who do you think is doing best after last night? lol I am curious how they all did.

[SharonA]

I really enjoyed last night. I think it was one of the best shows yet. Jason sang my favorite version of "Somewhere Over the Rainbow". I though it was his best performance yet.

[leelee88]

Well, My opinion is Christy is really starting to shine! And I really like Brooke but I just don't know what has happened with her.. The Jason boy really did Over the Rainbow really nicely.. David Cook was ok and I am a fan of his.. But it was not his best! And the Aussie guy, I think did really well.. As for Carley who I also like, just tried to tackle a big song and her voice got weak at the end! And I can not think of the other girls name but she tackled a Fantashia song and did pretty good with it! And Little David sang very well while playing the piano..

[Claredale]

Didn't anyone recognize Jason's version. I guess y'all are avid ER fans like me. I still record the reruns everyday. I told y'all I watch alot of TV! That is the song the played when Dr. Green passed away in Hawaii. I still cry everytime I hear that version on the song. I had it as my ringtone on my phone for a while. And Jason did a very good job of it. Just as Simon said. "Fantastic". I am a huge Martina McBride fan, which is why I fell in love with Carrie so quickly since she was too. Kristy did a great job of it.

Did anyone notice that no one booed Simon when he critizied Carley last night. I don't even think the audience got into to it either. I kept saying that she was back to her angry tone of her voice. It's so up in the air on who will be the bottom 3. I think it's Carley's turn based on the performances last night. David Cook tried to be different. It just didn't work this time. But we know he has plenty of talent! Aussie of course, is doing well. I think little David was having to concentrate on his piano playing a little too much which took some away from his performance, but like Randy said when he stoppled playing for a little bit, his runs were so wonderful. Brooke doesn't have much longer, but I have so enjoyed her being on the show. Her eyes show every emotion she has.

Now for Paula...She needed to wear so clothes last night. She made me feel so uncomfortable! Every time she lifted her arms, I thought we might get a wardrobe malfunction. Tonight will be a fun show with alot of the singers and actors on the show. I am looking forward to it.

One more thing....I am so tired of the judges telling the contestants that they can't compete with Whitney Houston, Celine Dion, and now Fantasia. First of all when Fantasia sang that song when she won American Idol a few years ago, she would have had such much emotion even if she was singing "I'm a little teacup!". Please I thought Sye did a wonderful job with that song, even better than Fantasia's recorded version.
****Okay, I am off my soapbox*******

[leelee88]

LOL Tracey!! I SO have to agree with you about Paula and her dress or what ever that was she was wearing!.. That just was not something to wear..lol

Oh BTW tonights show is going to be about Idol Gives Back! So we will not know the results on who is booted until Thursday..

[Berkshire Road]

Syesha Mercado, Syesha Mercado, Syesha Mercado. That's the "other girl's" name. Syesha Mercado. SIGH EEE SHA

If you missed it last night (like me) you can usually see the performances on youtube.

[SharonA]

When it was said that Syesha did not do as well as Fantasia, I said the same thing. She had just won for goodness sakes. Besides...Unless these people sing a song they wrote or someone else wrote the song just for them...someone else has sung every other song before them. Sheesh!!!! Syesaha was fantastic last night.

[leelee88]

LOL Carlolyn.. I just cant remember her name.. geesh but I love her voice..But I promise I got it now..(Syesha Mercado)

[leelee88]

I am in shock that they cut Micheal!! But I guess they all after go at some point!

[lisabar36]

I was SO shocked. I didn't think it was time for him to go yet. I thought it was time for Carly to go. :(

[leelee88]

Yes Lisa, I have to agree on that one! Carleys song and performance was not near as good as Micheals in my opinion..

[SharonA]

Hubby and I were both shocked that he was voted off.

[Claredale]

I am so going to miss the beautiful Aussie! I just know that American Idol is just his jumping off point. He has alot of talent!

Carley was my choice to go. I think she thought so too. That's is why I wish we could call in to vote off not to try vote people to stay on. That's what they did with the best comedian reality shows. You could only vote 3 times I think from each number, but it seemed more fair.

But like was posted earlier, they will all be voted off eventually. I keep reminding myself, they all have a tour to look forward too where they will make money and get more exposure and the ability to improve their talents.

I really enjoyed Terri Hatcher singing Carrie Underwood's song on Wednesday night with the "TV Band". I knew "Mike" the plumber on Desperate Housewives played, but it was fun to pick out the other people playing in the band. The guy from Heros played the drums.

Tracey